MAHIL DOLE
COLOMBO :Thus is an extremely relevant and sensitive example, One that captures the real-world tension between faith, identity, and modern visibility. The case of a Muslim woman athlete winning a major event yet being judged primarily for her attire reflects a deeper moral and sociological conflict within the global Muslim community. Let’s unpack this carefully and constructively.
- The Core Issue
The issue here isn’t merely about clothing — it’s about how we interpret Islam in the modern world.
This case exposes the clash between two legitimate impulses:
The religious impulse — to protect modesty and uphold Islamic values of haya’ (modesty) and ‘iffah (dignity).
The aspirational impulse — to celebrate excellence, human achievement, and the contribution of Muslims to the global stage.
When the conversation shifts from achievement to appearance, it suggests that we as a community are struggling to balance faith with reality.
- Understanding Context and Intent
In Islam, intention (niyyah) matters profoundly.
The athlete’s purpose was not to rebel against faith but to compete, represent her nation, and inspire others.
Athletic uniforms are largely standardized by international federations; deviation often leads to disqualification.
Thus, what may appear as a breach of modesty might in reality be a constraint of circumstance, not a rejection of Islamic values.
This connects directly to the legal maxim you mentioned earlier —
“Necessity makes permissible what is otherwise prohibited” (al-darūrāt tubīḥ al-maḥẓūrāt).
If her participation required a specific uniform to compete, and her intent was pure, then her situation falls under darurah (necessity) — not defiance.
- When and Where to Draw the Line
Applying the earlier framework:
WHEN:
When we risk losing the moral narrative — when discussion of modesty overshadows compassion, achievement, or representation.
At that moment, it’s time to redirect focus from judgment to understanding.
WHERE:
Within the hearts and minds of the community, the line should be drawn between guidance and condemnation.
We should uphold the principle of modesty — but without alienating or shaming those who represent us with dignity on the world stage. - WHY We Must Rethink Our Response
The Qur’an calls the Muslim community “ummatan wasatan” — a balanced community (Al-Baqarah 2:143).
This means that while values are non-negotiable, our approach must remain moderate and wise.
If we publicly shame a woman for competing, instead of celebrating her achievement, we risk:
Alienating younger generations who already feel Islam is misunderstood.
Sending a message that faith and excellence cannot coexist.
Turning personal piety into a public policing mechanism, rather than an inner moral compass.
- WHO Should Lead This Discourse
This is where religious scholars, educators, and community leaders play a crucial role.
They must:
Clarify that Islam honors human effort and encourages Muslims to excel in all fields.
Emphasize that modesty is a principle, not a uniform — it varies across context, climate, and circumstance.
Create safe spaces for dialogue, so young Muslims can succeed globally without being torn between faith and identity.
- HOW to Move Forward
a. Reframe the Narrative
Instead of: “She wore shorts,”
Say: “She carried the flag, broke barriers, and inspired a generation.”
A faithful community learns to correct privately and celebrate publicly.
b. Institutional Guidance
Islamic federations, sports councils, and cultural organizations can:
Advocate for modest athletic uniforms that meet international standards (like the hijab-friendly sportswear introduced in global events).
Provide religious advisory boards to support athletes in balancing performance and faith.
c. Encourage Dialogue, Not Division
Use this moment to teach that Islam is about dignity, not harshness — that every victory of a Muslim is a victory for the Ummah, even when the path is imperfect.
- The Deeper Lesson
This incident is not a failure of faith, but a test of community maturity.
The real question is not whether she crossed the line — but whether we know how and when to draw it.
Islamic integrity is not about isolating Muslims from the modern world, but about guiding them through it with wisdom and mercy.
As the Qur’an says: “And thus We have made you a balanced nation that you may be witnesses over the people.” (2:143)
الحمدُ للهِ
